Pimento cheese, often affectionately dubbed the “pâté of the South,” is far more than just a spread; it’s a culinary institution. This creamy, savory delight has roots deep in Southern tradition, yet its universal appeal means you can now find it gracing menus and deli counters across the United States. Its incredible versatility makes it a perfect companion for almost anything, from simple crackers to gourmet charcuterie boards. While there are countless variations on this beloved classic, our unique homemade Southern Pimento Cheese recipe stands out with an amazing texture and an unforgettable flavor profile that elevates it beyond the ordinary. Prepare to discover your new favorite appetizer, sandwich filling, or a delightful addition to any meal!
What Exactly is Pimento Cheese?
At its core, pimento cheese is a simple yet profoundly satisfying spread. Historically, its earliest forms often combined canned pimentos with cream cheese and a handful of other basic ingredients. Over time, this humble concoction evolved into the Southern staple we know today, almost universally featuring four key components: cream cheese, jarred or canned pimentos (small, sweet cherry peppers), sharp cheddar cheese, and mayonnaise. These ingredients form the foundation, creating a rich, tangy, and slightly sweet base that is endlessly adaptable.
However, the beauty of pimento cheese lies in its regional diversity and countless variations. Across the vast Southern landscape, and indeed throughout the nation, cooks have added their personal touches, leading to a vibrant tapestry of recipes. You’ll encounter versions ranging from mild to fiery, chunky to silky smooth. This widespread adaptation means that while a core flavor profile remains consistent—creamy, cheesy, with a distinct pimento sweetness—there’s no single, rigidly “traditional” recipe anymore, and that’s perfectly fine! This culinary freedom allows for endless creativity and the discovery of exciting new flavor combinations, much like the one we’re about to share.
Crafting Our Signature Easy Homemade Southern Pimento Cheese
While adhering to the classic base of cream cheese, pimentos, cheddar, and mayonnaise, our recipe takes a delightful detour to enhance both flavor and texture, resulting in a pimento cheese that truly stands out. We believe these thoughtful additions transform a good recipe into an extraordinary one, offering a unique gourmet experience you won’t easily find elsewhere. We’re confident that once you try it, you might just declare this the best pimento cheese recipe you’ve ever tasted!
Our first innovation involves the inclusion of mascarpone cheese alongside traditional cream cheese. Mascarpone, an Italian-style cream cheese renowned for its incredibly rich and buttery texture, contributes an unparalleled creaminess and subtle sweetness that deepens the overall luxuriousness of the spread. While you can certainly stick to just cream cheese for a delicious result, the mascarpone elevates the texture to a velvety smoothness that is simply divine. It adds a sophisticated layer that makes each bite feel indulgent and wonderfully satisfying.
Secondly, we’ve swapped out a portion of the mayonnaise for sour cream. This isn’t just a whim; it’s a carefully considered choice based on personal preference for a balanced flavor. The sour cream introduces a delicate acidity that cuts through the richness of the cheeses and mayonnaise, preventing the spread from feeling too heavy. This subtle tang provides a refreshing contrast, brightening the overall taste profile and adding a layer of complexity that keeps you coming back for more.
Finally, for those who appreciate a hint of heat, our recipe incorporates a finely diced serrano pepper and a pinch of cayenne pepper. These spicy additions are carefully measured to provide just enough warmth to make the pimento cheese more intriguing without overwhelming the delicate flavors of the cheese and pimentos. The heat level is fully adjustable, allowing you to tailor it to your palate—dial it up for a bolder kick or reduce it for a milder experience. The remaining ingredients, such as onion powder, kosher salt, Worcestershire sauce, and black pepper, are straightforward and work in harmony to build a well-rounded and deeply flavorful spread.
Sourcing Your Pimento Peppers: A Quick Guide
Pimento peppers, also known as cherry peppers due to their sweet, mild, and heart-shaped appearance, are an indispensable ingredient in pimento cheese. For convenience and consistent quality, we always opt for jarred or canned versions. These are readily available in most major grocery stores. You’ll typically find them in the condiments aisle, nestled among pickles, olives, and other jarred vegetables. Just remember to double-check if they come pre-diced; if not, a quick chop at home is all it takes. Be sure to drain them well before adding them to your mixture to prevent excess moisture from compromising the spread’s creamy texture. For those who prefer the ease of online shopping, pimentos are also widely available through retailers like Amazon.
Choosing the Best Cheddar Cheese for Pimento Perfection
The type of cheddar cheese you use significantly impacts the final flavor of your pimento cheese, making it one of the most crucial ingredients. For an authentic and robust taste, we strongly recommend using sharp cheddar cheese. Alternatively, extra-sharp cheddar will provide an even bolder, more pronounced cheesy flavor that truly shines through. Avoid mild cheddar cheese, as its subtle taste tends to get lost among the other ingredients, resulting in a less satisfying spread. The depth of flavor from sharp cheddar is what gives pimento cheese its distinctive character.
Beyond the type, the preparation of your cheddar is also key. We wholeheartedly advocate for shredding the cheese yourself from a block rather than purchasing pre-shredded varieties. While pre-shredded cheese offers convenience, it often contains anti-caking agents like cellulose or potato starch, which can alter the texture of your pimento cheese, sometimes making it gritty or less creamy. Freshly shredded cheddar, however, melts more smoothly and incorporates seamlessly into the spread, contributing to that luxurious, homemade feel. The effort of shredding your own cheese is a small step that yields a noticeably superior result in terms of both texture and flavor, ensuring your pimento cheese is as rich and creamy as possible.
Creative and Classic Ways to Savor Pimento Cheese
Pimento cheese’s fame extends far beyond just a simple cracker spread. For golf enthusiasts, the mention of pimento cheese immediately brings to mind the iconic pimento cheese sandwiches served at The Masters Tournament held annually at Augusta National Golf Club in Augusta, Georgia. But the possibilities for incorporating this incredible cheese spread into your culinary repertoire are virtually endless. Here are some of our absolute favorite ways to enjoy its rich and creamy goodness:
Delectable Sandwiches, Burgers, and Hot Dogs
- Classic Sandwiches: The simplest approach is to spread pimento cheese generously between two slices of soft white bread. For a more refined touch, you can trim off the crusts, creating elegant tea-style sandwiches. However, for those seeking a more comforting and indulgent experience, a lightly grilled cheese sandwich featuring pimento cheese is an absolute game-changer. The warmth coaxes out even more flavor from the cheese and creates a delightfully gooey interior.
- Elevated Deli Sandwiches: Transform your everyday turkey or ham sandwich by spreading a layer of pimento cheese instead of mayonnaise or aioli. It adds a vibrant, tangy, and savory kick that takes your lunch to a new level.
- Gourmet Burgers: Move beyond traditional cheddar on your burger and top it with a generous dollop of pimento cheese. As it warms, it melts beautifully, creating a rich, savory topping that complements the beef perfectly.
- Hot Dog Perfection: Don’t underestimate the power of pimento cheese on a hot dog. Its creamy texture and bold flavor make it an outstanding condiment, adding a Southern twist to this backyard barbecue favorite.
Impressive Cheese and Charcuterie Boards
Pimento cheese is a natural star on any cheese or charcuterie board. Its bright color and inviting texture make it an irresistible centerpiece. Serve it alongside a variety of crisp crackers, thin slices of toasted baguette, or other crusty breads. For a refreshing and healthy option, pair it with fresh crudités like crisp celery sticks, vibrant carrot sticks, cool cucumber slices, or colorful bell pepper strips. It’s an ideal dip that adds both flavor and visual appeal to any spread, perfectly balancing richer meats and cheeses.
Beyond the Spread: Creative Culinary Uses
Don’t limit pimento cheese to just being a spread! It’s an incredibly versatile ingredient that can elevate many dishes:
- Mac & Cheese Enhancement: Stirring a few spoonfuls of pimento cheese into an otherwise standard mac and cheese recipe can transform it into a gourmet experience. The pimentos and extra sharp cheddar add depth and a wonderful tang.
- Stuffed Peppers: Use it as a rich and flavorful stuffing for bell peppers or jalapeños, baked until bubbly and golden.
- Quesadilla Filling: Spread a thin layer on tortillas before adding other fillings for a cheesy, savory quesadilla with a kick.
- Baked Potatoes or Loaded Fries: Top a hot baked potato or a pile of crispy fries with a spoonful of warm pimento cheese for an indulgent side dish.
- Deviled Eggs: Incorporate a small amount into your deviled egg filling for a surprising and delightful twist on a classic appetizer.
- Grilled Chicken or Fish Topping: A dollop over grilled chicken or white fish adds moisture and a burst of flavor.
Optimal Storage for Your Pimento Cheese
Proper storage is key to enjoying your homemade pimento cheese for as long as possible. When stored correctly in an airtight container, such as a jar with a tight-fitting lid, your pimento cheese will remain fresh and delicious in the refrigerator for up to 10 days. We find that the flavors meld beautifully over time, often tasting even better on the second or third day. For the best flavor and creamy texture, we prefer to let our pimento cheese come to room temperature for about 15-20 minutes before serving. However, if you enjoy it chilled, it’s perfectly acceptable to serve it straight from the fridge.
Savor Every Delicious Bite!
We truly hope you enjoy making and tasting this Easy Homemade Southern Pimento Cheese recipe as much as we do! It’s a recipe that brings joy and flavor to any occasion. If you try it and love it, please consider leaving us a comment and a 5-star rating below. Your feedback means the world to us and helps other home cooks discover this fantastic spread. Don’t forget to click the heart icon to like this recipe and share it with your friends and family! And, of course, we’d absolutely love to see your creations on Instagram—be sure to tag us @cooking_with_wine!
Craving more delightful recipes like this? Explore these other fan favorites:
- Pecan Jalapeño and Gouda Cheese Ball
- Roasted Poblano and Smoked Gouda Mac and Cheese
- Chicken Fried Steak with Ancho Poblano Gravy
- Best Texas Chili from Scratch
Recipe Card
Easy Homemade Southern Pimento Cheese Recipe
Pin Recipe
Ingredients
- 2 ½ cups (9 oz) shredded sharp cheddar cheese
- 6 oz cream cheese
- 2 oz mascarpone
- ¼ cup sour cream
- ¼ cup mayonnaise
- 4 oz diced pimentos (drained)
- 1 large serrano pepper – seeded and diced very small
- ½ teaspoon onion powder
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt (or more to taste)
- ½ teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
- Pinch black pepper
- Pinch cayenne pepper
Instructions
- Combine all ingredients into a large mixing bowl and mix thoroughly with a gloved hand or spatula. Alternatively, you can prepare the recipe using an electric mixer. Ensure the mixture is thoroughly combined, transfer to a jar, or serve immediately.